ajatola najavio da će konfiskuje bahrein emirate i tako te proksi državice ako ješo ameri budu nastavili da prave sranja

jedan je brat ajatola

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/06/SassanidEmpireTrueExtent.png

Gledaju cionisti kako da grunu Al Aksu i okrive Iran.

lepo ga spucali
https://x.com/i/status/2036858872363626676

Short answer: not as a sovereign, independent state in the modern sense—especially before 1947. But that doesn’t mean the name or identity didn’t exist. It did, just in a different form.

Here’s the clear breakdown:

⸻

1. Ancient and classical periods

The term “Palestine” goes way back, but not as an independent nation-state.
• The Romans renamed the region Syria Palaestina after crushing the Bar Kokhba revolt.
• It was an administrative region, not a self-governing country.

⸻

2. Islamic empires (7th century → early 1500s)

Under various caliphates (Umayyad, Abbasid, etc.):
• The area was known as Jund Filastin
• Again: a province within larger empires, not an independent state.

⸻

3. Ottoman Empire (1517–1917)

For 400 years under the Ottoman Empire:
• There was no political unit officially called “Palestine”
• The land was divided into districts like Vilayet of Beirut and the Mutasarrifate of Jerusalem

That said, the term “Palestine” was still used informally and geographically by locals and foreigners.

⸻

4. British Mandate (1917–1948)

This is the first time “Palestine” becomes an official political entity in modern terms:
• The League of Nations created the Mandatory Palestine
• It was governed by Britain—not independent

This is also when modern Palestinian Arab identity really consolidates politically, especially in response to Zionism and British rule.

⸻

5. 1947 turning point
• The United Nations proposed partition into Jewish and Arab states
• War followed → 1948 Arab–Israeli War
• Israel declared independence; no Arab Palestinian state emerged at that time

⸻

So what’s the honest conclusion?
• No, there was never a fully sovereign Palestinian state before 1947
• Yes, “Palestine” absolutely existed as:
• a geographic region
• an administrative term
• and eventually a developing national identity

⸻

Why this question gets heated

People often mix up two different things:
• “Was there a state?” → No
• “Did a people/identity tied to that land exist?” → Yes, especially by the 20th century

Both sides in the debate tend to cherry-pick one of those and ignore the other.

nači svašta se dešavalo kod ovi slepaca vekovima al:

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTCAnMMzjqiegVc7vFvZuhHZRZRzGtW_zN7GQ&s