ajatola najavio da će konfiskuje bahrein emirate i tako te proksi državice ako ješo ameri budu nastavili da prave sranja

jedan je brat ajatola

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/06/SassanidEmpireTrueExtent.png

Gledaju cionisti kako da grunu Al Aksu i okrive Iran.

lepo ga spucali
https://x.com/i/status/2036858872363626676

Short answer: not as a sovereign, independent state in the modern sense—especially before 1947. But that doesn’t mean the name or identity didn’t exist. It did, just in a different form.

Here’s the clear breakdown:

⸻

1. Ancient and classical periods

The term “Palestine” goes way back, but not as an independent nation-state.
• The Romans renamed the region Syria Palaestina after crushing the Bar Kokhba revolt.
• It was an administrative region, not a self-governing country.

⸻

2. Islamic empires (7th century → early 1500s)

Under various caliphates (Umayyad, Abbasid, etc.):
• The area was known as Jund Filastin
• Again: a province within larger empires, not an independent state.

⸻

3. Ottoman Empire (1517–1917)

For 400 years under the Ottoman Empire:
• There was no political unit officially called “Palestine”
• The land was divided into districts like Vilayet of Beirut and the Mutasarrifate of Jerusalem

That said, the term “Palestine” was still used informally and geographically by locals and foreigners.

⸻

4. British Mandate (1917–1948)

This is the first time “Palestine” becomes an official political entity in modern terms:
• The League of Nations created the Mandatory Palestine
• It was governed by Britain—not independent

This is also when modern Palestinian Arab identity really consolidates politically, especially in response to Zionism and British rule.

⸻

5. 1947 turning point
• The United Nations proposed partition into Jewish and Arab states
• War followed → 1948 Arab–Israeli War
• Israel declared independence; no Arab Palestinian state emerged at that time

⸻

So what’s the honest conclusion?
• No, there was never a fully sovereign Palestinian state before 1947
• Yes, “Palestine” absolutely existed as:
• a geographic region
• an administrative term
• and eventually a developing national identity

⸻

Why this question gets heated

People often mix up two different things:
• “Was there a state?” → No
• “Did a people/identity tied to that land exist?” → Yes, especially by the 20th century

Both sides in the debate tend to cherry-pick one of those and ignore the other.

nači svašta se dešavalo kod ovi slepaca vekovima al:

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTCAnMMzjqiegVc7vFvZuhHZRZRzGtW_zN7GQ&s

Gubimo vreme na ove nebitne teme ne bavimo se onim bitnim, Čeu jel voliš ragbi i jel vodiš decu na ragbi?

ranis li goluboe ceu

Izguglajte.

ceu mozes lagati neke ljude na saitu sve vreme, mozes i sve ljude na saitu lagati neko vreme, ali ne mozes na saitu lagati sve vreme sve ljude

Ne možeš samog sebe lagati baš sve vreme Čeu.

Eto, lepo i pristojno vam sve objasnim rečima, (možda sam trebao slikama), a vi kad ste shvatili da ste živeli u zabludi dok nisam uneo u vaše ćivote svetlost saznanja pokušate da napravite digresiju na ragbi i golubove, okačite mi bez ikakve osnove da sam lažov i još mi decu upletete u priču.
To je manjak osnovnog kućnog odgoja i kulture, neke stvari koje ako te roditelji ne nauče do sedme godine posle nikada ne naučiš.

nije bas ta retorika al seseljuga/udbasko spinovanje je ostalo u dusi/modi vidim

Eto, vidiš da možeš da budeš iskren kad se opisuješ. Nije teško.
Nema na čemu.

bidim

Onaj koji nikada nije napravio grešku u kucanju neka baci prvi kamen.

Ali dobro, onaj koji se davi hvata se i za poslednju, najnižu slamku.

ozbiljno si kiseo decko, revidiraj profilnu sliku sredi ćivot

uh a izrael ti je drzava samo takva..velicine vojvodine.pa to jevreji sad mogu da kupe od vucica i da kazu evo ovo je nasa suverena DRZAVA.vucic bi im ladno prodao vojvodinu nego njih ne zanima ta lokacija.tvrde da im je bog obecao neku zemlju, nema problema, cim bog bude sisao da to licno potvrdi, ja mislim da ce svi vrlo rado da izadju u susret, nece niko da pravi problem

ova tema treba da dobije pravilo-nije dozvoljeno biti na strani izaraela.ko kaze nesto pozitivno o smrdljivom izaraelu ban mesec dana.
danas vidim sliku hitlera i ispod pise-thanks for trying hahahh

isto su radili i u to vreme, stim da je tu propagandu bilo daleko lakse prodati

prica o jesama i masovnom stradanju je false fleg tog vremena. Naravno da su zrtvovali svoje radi propagande.

Žrtvovali su i 9/11